• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Muldoon's on Main: A Taste of New American Cuisine in Carmel, IN

At Muldoon's on Main, a vibrant New American pub located in Carmel, history and flavor collide in an inviting atmosphere. As a women-owned establishment, it prides itself on serving diverse, mouthwatering dishes like expertly seasoned sandwiches and fresh salads, all with a hearty dose of hospitality. Guests can enjoy casual dining, outdoor seating, and happy hour specials that beckon patrons to unwind. Whether it's a tenderloin sandwich that leaves you craving more or giant onion rings that are an experience in themselves, Muldoon's offers a distinctive blend of flavors and community spirit, making it a cherished favorite for families and friends alike.

Muldoon's on Main at a glance

  • Address 111 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032
  • Phone (317) 571-1116
  • Restaurant type Irish pub , American restaurant , Restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Muldoon's on Main: Reviews & Ratings

Robin Hultman
4

Prices were a tad high for a few of the side items. The Tenderloin meal is DEFINITELY a great deal and so delicious!

Andrew Sharpe
5

Recently went back here after years of not eating here. Not because I didn't like it, but because of what I typically eat. Anyways saw a review on social media about their breaded pork tenderloin, so my construction crew went there for lunch to try. We got seated immediately and the place was immaculate clean with a very nice atmosphere. Our server was very nice, polite and knowledgeable. Two of us order the smaller BPT and got French as well. My other coworker has gluten allergy and went with the buffalo chicken salad. The sandwiches were amazing and I was glad I got the smaller one because I would've been wasting food as the smaller one was more than enough to eat. The fries were also very good. And both my coworkers loved their food. I will be going back more often now to try more of their menu.

Dylan St. Clair
5

We really liked a lot about Muldoon's. Portion size was massive, especially for the price. We really liked the indoor aesthetic. And the food was very tasty. We had went to another restaurant nearby. They had a 45 minute wait for a table. We went here at random and were quite happy with our choice.

Rebecca Long
5

What a great experience! I took my 93 yo mother and a friend here for dinner on a Thursday around 8pm. It was perfect weather to eat outside which was clean and not crowded. Our waiter, John, was a gem. He even asked the bartender to try to make a German radler for me. It was great! I haven't had a good one since I was in Germany! I ordered the battered fish sandwich with onion rings as a side. The fish batter was superb - Crispy and not too greasy. I think the same batter was on the onions. The side of onion was just 2 HUGE slices but plenty! I took half my sandwich home. The other 2 ppl ordered half sandwich (chicken salad) and cup of soup. Both were impressed. We all agreed we'd come back again soon! If this review was helpful, please give it a

Zeenat Joshi
5

Went for drinks and snacks. The onions rings were nice and crisp...too thick for me though. They have a nice casual atmosphere, fun vibes. Neat and clean. Would go back. Christine was our server, very attentive and personable.

Dr Alo
5

Great food. Little sandwiches, burgers, salads. Great atmosphere. You'll really enjoy it! Highly recommend!

Mikka Mabius
5

Fall menu has started! Pot roast was amazingly delicious and chicken tenders were huge! Love their sweet tea and Debbie our server was great :)

D Scalos
5

Patty welcomed us and Brenda was very attentive! Our lunch was perfect! They have a nice variety of items on their menu. Great atmosphere and they have their patio enclosed during winter weather!! We were pleasantly surprised to meet Patty when we were contemplating where to eat. She came outside and greeted us & welcomed us in!!!! So fun and this is definitely the place to be!! John took wonderful care of anything we needed. The food was ABSOLUTELY perfect!!! We ordered the Patty Melt with seasoned fries & Black and Bleu Burger with salad!!! There are no words to describe it. What a great atmosphere and all around experience!!! They have a wonderful patio with fans. Definitely the place to enjoy your lunch!!

Location

  • Muldoon's on Main
    Muldoon's on Main
    111 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032 Hotline: (317) 571-1116

Welcome to Muldoon's on Main, a delightful New American pub nestled at 111 W Main St, Carmel, IN. This vibrant eatery stands out not just for its flavorful menu but for its warm, inviting atmosphere, ideal for families, friends, and casual gatherings.

What Makes Muldoon's Shine:

  • Diverse Menu: From mouthwatering appetizers like the Buffalo Chicken Wings and Skewered Fried Cheese to refreshing salads such as the Crab Cake Salad and Black Bleu Salad, there’s something for everyone. Don’t forget to indulge in their delectable desserts like the Chocolate Volcano Cake.
  • Community Vibes: As a women-owned establishment, Muldoon's fosters a strong sense of community. Whether you're laughing with friends over a Grilled Chicken Quesadilla or enjoying a drink at the bar, the friendly staff, including noted favorites like Dawn and Brenda, make sure you feel right at home.
  • Fun Atmosphere: With casual outdoor seating, a pool table, and even live music, this is the perfect spot to unwind. Many patrons have praised the moderate noise level, allowing for good conversation without shouting.
  • Accessibility: Muldoon’s is fully wheelchair accessible and offers a variety of payment options including cryptocurrency. Plus, they are pet-friendly, ensuring everyone in your party feels welcomed.

Customer Experience:

Erin S. captures the spirit well: “Booze? - check. Friendly staff? - check. Super tasty chicken quesadilla? - check.” This sentiment is echoed throughout various reviews highlighting the flavorful food, strong drinks, and great company found at Muldoon’s. Julian H. also raves about the Sunday Brunch, emphasizing not just the value but the quality.

Whether it’s a casual lunch or a lively dinner with friends, Muldoon’s on Main provides a culinary experience infused with a welcoming spirit. Stop by for Happy Hour specials on Monday, Wednesday, and Friday—your tastebuds will thank you!

For reservations, call (317) 571-1116 and get ready to savor the best of New American cuisine in a cozy pub setting. Don’t miss out on this local gem!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards